Deus Sive Qualia III: The Trinity of Being

Intention, Attention, Extension

"If consciousness is not an anomaly in a dead universe, but the very fabric of reality itself, then how does it operate? What are its fundamental mechanics?"

In our journey through the landscape of panqualia, we've established consciousness as fundamental rather than emergent, and explored how it might permeate all levels of existence. But a crucial question remains: How does this universal consciousness actually function? What are its basic operating principles?

The answer, I propose, lies in a trinity of forces that together form the combinatorial structure of qualia space: Intention, Attention, and Extension. Like three primary colors mixing to create every possible hue, these three aspects combine to generate the infinite variety of conscious experience.

Intention: The Will of Matter

Consider an electron in a magnetic field. The conventional view sees it as merely following physical laws, devoid of any inner experience. But what if its behavior - its apparent "attraction" to the magnetic source - is actually an expression of something more fundamental? What we externally observe as force and motion might internally be experienced as intention and will.

This is not to anthropomorphize the electron or suggest it has human-like desires. Rather, it's to recognize that even at this most basic level, there exists a kind of directedness, a primitive "striving" that manifests physically as causal behavior and experientially as the most rudimentary form of will.

In human consciousness, intention appears as our goals, desires, and volitions. But these are merely complex elaborations of a principle that extends all the way down to the quantum realm - the principle that every entity, at every scale, has an inherent directedness toward certain states rather than others.

Attention: The Focus of Being

If intention is the "will" of existence, attention is its "awareness." Just as iron is highly "attentive" to magnetic fields while plastic remains oblivious, different configurations of matter exhibit different capacities for registering and responding to aspects of their environment. We humans are not conscious of the WiFi signals passing through us, but our phones are exquisitely tuned to these frequencies.

Attention, then, is not a uniquely human faculty but a universal feature of reality - the capacity of systems to be differentially responsive to their environment. What varies is not the presence or absence of attention, but its scope, resolution, and complexity.

This explains why we can only be conscious of what we can interact with: attention and causal interaction are two sides of the same coin. The boundaries of our conscious experience are defined by the boundaries of our possible interactions with the world.

Extension: The Dance of Communication

The third principle, extension, completes the trinity by describing how these individual centers of experience - these points of intention and attention - relate to and influence each other. When an electron's "will" meets the "will" of a proton, what emerges is not chaos but a dance of negotiation, a finding of equilibrium that we observe as atomic bonding.

This principle scales up through all levels of reality. From quantum entanglement to chemical reactions, from neural signaling to human conversation, extension is how separate experiences combine and communicate to create higher-order unities of consciousness.

The Combinatorial Web of Experience: A 360-Degree Tug of War

To understand how these three principles - Intention, Attention, and Extension - combine to create more complex forms of experience, imagine a vast circular arena where countless micro-qualia engage in a perpetual tug of war. Each element pulls with its own specific intensity and direction, representing its particular valence and preference.

This dynamic interplay creates a fascinating choreography: some qualia reinforce each other, pulling in harmony, while others neutralize each other's influence. Some maintain a constant tension, while others provide only momentary tugs. The result is a dynamic equilibrium where the state of the whole system (represented by the position within the circle) continuously shifts without ever coming to rest.

This metaphor helps us understand how complex conscious states arise from simpler experiential elements. Each micro-experience contributes its part to the overall experience, yet none determines it completely. It is the subtle interplay of all components - their "tug of war" over the direction of intention and attention.
It’s the "coloring" of multidimensional interest and experiences - that generate the flowing landscapes of consciousness we experience from within.

We rarely become aware of the countless "micro-decisions" that constitute our experience from moment to moment. However, through methods like mindfulness meditation, it becomes possible to break down the seemingly seamless surface of the consciousness stream into its elementary components and grasp the dynamics of "qualia integration" with ever greater subtlety.

The Dance of Integration

When basic sense cells first experience the pure physical perception of acting forces through elementary qualia, this information can be perceived and evaluated in the next step by other cells. A third cluster can then evaluate information about the activity of both groups and put them in relation to each other. With each additional level, the information from the previous ones can be compared, utilized, and integrated.

The result is a vastly richer and self-referential experiential world that explains the complexity of our consciousness without requiring any form of strong emergence. It's not that something new suddenly appears - rather, the existing elements of experience combine and recombine in increasingly sophisticated patterns, like the individual instruments in an orchestra coming together to create a symphony.

This process is simultaneous with the physical complexity we observe - each new level of material integration corresponds to a higher level of qualia synthesis. Micro-experiences recursively merge into macro-experiences - up to globally integrated experiential gestalts like our sense of self or the phenomenal first-person perspective.

The boundaries of this integration process don't stop at the limits of our brains. Everywhere information jumps from A to B, there exists a network of experienced reality. This leads to a hierarchy of fractal conscious experiences at all levels of existence, each level adding its own unique pattern to the great tug of war of universal experience.

What we experience as our unified consciousness is thus not a singular, isolated phenomenon, but rather a particularly complex and highly integrated node in an infinite web of experiential relations. Every thought, every feeling, every moment of awareness is a unique configuration in this endless dance of qualia, each pulling and being pulled in the great circular arena of being.

Understanding consciousness in this way - as a dynamic balance of countless experiential forces rather than a monolithic phenomenon - opens new avenues for both scientific investigation and philosophical insight. It suggests that what we call "mind" is neither a thing nor a process, but a pattern of relationships in the vast web of universal experience.

This vision maintains both the unity we experience subjectively and the complexity we observe objectively, without needing to invoke any mysterious forces or unexplainable jumps in nature. It shows us how the simplest forms of experience can combine to create the rich tapestry of conscious life, while remaining true to both physical law and phenomenological reality.

Implications and Horizons

This framework has profound implications. It suggests that consciousness isn't just fundamental but structured - not a homogeneous field but a space of possibilities defined by these three axes. It implies that any system capable of intention, attention, and extension must have some form of experience, however primitive.

Moreover, it provides a potential bridge between subjective experience and objective observation. What we externally observe as physical causation, detection, and interaction might be internally experienced as intention, attention, and extension. The "inside" and "outside" views of reality are thus revealed as complementary perspectives on the same underlying processes.

This also opens new avenues for understanding phenomena like quantum measurement, the entropy defiance of life, and the evolution of consciousness. Perhaps what we call "measurement" in quantum mechanics is really an interaction between different scales of attention. Perhaps what we call "life" is a particular way of balancing and integrating these three principles.

Looking Forward

As we continue our exploration of consciousness as a fundamental feature of reality, this trinity of principles offers a powerful conceptual framework. It suggests that consciousness isn't just everywhere - it's everywhere in a structured, comprehensible way.

The challenge ahead lies in testing and refining these ideas, in finding ways to map the combinatorial space of consciousness more precisely. But already, this framework offers a new way of thinking about our place in the cosmos - not as isolated islands of consciousness in a dead sea of matter, but as complex expressions of principles that permeate all of reality.

The universe, seen this way, is neither a lifeless mechanism nor a mystical unity, but a vast matrix of interacting experiences, each shaped by the eternal dance of intention, attention, and extension. We are not separate from this dance but its most intricate expression - moments when the universe's capacity for experience has folded back on itself in patterns of unprecedented complexity.

---

Next: "The relationship between panqualia and quantum mechanics"